Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Question about the origin of a specific E.J. quote

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Question about the origin of a specific E.J. quote

    I am finishing up an M.A. in Linguistics and the final requirement is to write my dissertation. I have chosen as a topic evaluative and ideologically-loaded metaphors in business media discourse, specifically as they relate to gold as an asset class. A few years ago, I copied and pasted a specific quote by E.J. from this site into a word document file, and I would be very grateful if someone could kindly let me know the origin of it by posting the Itulip link so that I might view the original source of it. This is so that I could reference it in my dissertation as long as it is from an Itulip link that is publicly available (this remains to be seen). Here is the quote:


    "A high gold price is a major embarrassment to central bankers. When I got in the gold price was still giving central bankers an A for the fine job they did running a 30-year credit bubble and making everyone rich. At $1750 the gold market is giving central bankers a C. At $2500 they will be giving the central banks a D and at $5000 plus an F, at which point a clear Plan B will already be underway and visible to the connected and/or astute." --Eric Janszen



    Thank you in advance for taking the time to reply!

  • #2
    Re: Question about the origin of a specific E.J. quote

    VERY INTERESTING paper this well be, Uroshnor - will be on the edge of my seat awaiting Mr J on this one...

    thanks for the question - as i'm sure LOTS of 'tulipers will be as well.

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Question about the origin of a specific E.J. quote

      Originally posted by Uroshnor View Post
      I am finishing up an M.A. in Linguistics and the final requirement is to write my dissertation. I have chosen as a topic evaluative and ideologically-loaded metaphors in business media discourse, specifically as they relate to gold as an asset class. A few years ago, I copied and pasted a specific quote by E.J. from this site into a word document file, and I would be very grateful if someone could kindly let me know the origin of it by posting the Itulip link so that I might view the original source of it. This is so that I could reference it in my dissertation as long as it is from an Itulip link that is publicly available (this remains to be seen). Here is the quote:


      "A high gold price is a major embarrassment to central bankers. When I got in the gold price was still giving central bankers an A for the fine job they did running a 30-year credit bubble and making everyone rich. At $1750 the gold market is giving central bankers a C. At $2500 they will be giving the central banks a D and at $5000 plus an F, at which point a clear Plan B will already be underway and visible to the connected and/or astute." --Eric Janszen



      Thank you in advance for taking the time to reply!
      advanced site search function... this.

      can you share your dissertation with us pls?

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Question about the origin of a specific E.J. quote

        Originally posted by metalman View Post
        advanced site search function... this.

        can you share your dissertation with us pls?
        metalman, you have always amazed me with your ability to quickly pull up an old iTulip reference.
        And I will second your motion requesting the dissertation to read -seems pretty interesting.

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Question about the origin of a specific E.J. quote

          Originally posted by metalman View Post
          advanced site search function... this.
          HOW did you do that??? I've tried many times to use the search tool here and find it next to useless.

          Be kinder than necessary because everyone you meet is fighting some kind of battle.

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Question about the origin of a specific E.J. quote

            Yes, I can certainly share it once it is written. I am in the act of researching for it and composing it as I go. It is due in early September. I've built a specialized corpus of representative newspaper articles, although I'm limiting myself to only this recent gold bull market--this is not a diachronic study. The articles are either reporting on the gold price movement or op-ed commentaries, from 2001 to 2014 from the New York Times, Business Weekly, MarketWatch, and the Wall Street Journal. It has 54,000 words in it, which is more than I need for representativeness, but I wanted enough texts in the sub-corpora as well. This is actually a cross-disciplinary methodology, since it incorporates two separate fields--Corpus Linguistics, which analyzes texts via computers, and Critical Discourse Analysis, which focuses on the features of texts to reveal hidden ideologies and bias. But as I said, I'm focusing on metaphors, and in this regard the cross-fertilization of CDA and Corpus Linguistics has come to be known as Critical Metaphor Analysis from Charteris-Black (2004). There are already some interesting findings. In English, the system of Appraisal or Evaluation entail comparisons--this goes back to the sociolinguistic studies of Labov (1972) where certain varieties of English are favored over others.

            Applied specifically to gold, the types of metaphors used in the articles appear to instantiate a very negative ideological stance, even when just ostensibly reporting the news. Thus, the authors are revealing their subjective bias even in supposedly giving objective facts. As I said, this is on a comparative basis, so when the dollar is said to fall, or oil, or other metals, they "fell", but when gold falls, it is "crashing", "plunging", "undergoing a brutal decline", or "gold falls of a cliff". It is as though the authors are attempting to make the readers feel that there is something extremely negative about a small gold decline, whereas--at least in this corpus of texts--they do not use the same metaphors for other asset classes. Another one that I've focused on is GOLD INVESTMENT IS GAMBLING (it's the convention to put the Conceptual Metaphors in capitals). So authors say things like, "gold bugs are scrambling to reverse their bets," or "speculators are placing bets on lower gold prices", which makes gold investors appear like idiots who are only gamblers, and not using their intelligence to invest in gold. Again, these types of metaphors are not present to any significant degree in relation to other asset classes, so the bias is demonstrated from the comparative nature of the study. And of course, calling someone a "gold bug" is evaluative to a significant degree. Business discourse in general uses a lot of animal metaphors, such as bulls and bears, to represent different market actions, but it appears that gold investors are considered such a fringe that it necessitated naming them their own animal species in metaphorical terms in business discourse.

            Anyway, I wasn't able to use the search function. Could someone post the link to the webpage where that quote is located? I would really appreciate it. I will let you know more about my dissertation once I make more progress on it. There are certainly pedagogical implications. Even native speakers tend to be unaware of the types of values--and what are termed latent ideologically-loaded metaphors--that are contained in the business texts they get their news from.

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Question about the origin of a specific E.J. quote

              Originally posted by thriftyandboringinohio View Post
              metalman, you have always amazed me with your ability to quickly pull up an old iTulip reference.
              And I will second your motion requesting the dissertation to read -seems pretty interesting.
              yes indeed...

              Originally posted by shiny! View Post
              HOW did you do that??? I've tried many times to use the search tool here and find it next to useless.
              methinks its just because MM just knows/remembers where all the good bones are buried...

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Question about the origin of a specific E.J. quote

                Originally posted by Uroshnor View Post
                Yes, I can certainly share it once it is written. I am in the act of researching for it and composing it as I go. It is due in early September. I've built a specialized corpus of representative newspaper articles, although I'm limiting myself to only this recent gold bull market--this is not a diachronic study. The articles are either reporting on the gold price movement or op-ed commentaries, from 2001 to 2014 from the New York Times, Business Weekly, MarketWatch, and the Wall Street Journal. It has 54,000 words in it, which is more than I need for representativeness, but I wanted enough texts in the sub-corpora as well. This is actually a cross-disciplinary methodology, since it incorporates two separate fields--Corpus Linguistics, which analyzes texts via computers, and Critical Discourse Analysis, which focuses on the features of texts to reveal hidden ideologies and bias. But as I said, I'm focusing on metaphors, and in this regard the cross-fertilization of CDA and Corpus Linguistics has come to be known as Critical Metaphor Analysis from Charteris-Black (2004). There are already some interesting findings. In English, the system of Appraisal or Evaluation entail comparisons--this goes back to the sociolinguistic studies of Labov (1972) where certain varieties of English are favored over others.

                Applied specifically to gold, the types of metaphors used in the articles appear to instantiate a very negative ideological stance, even when just ostensibly reporting the news. Thus, the authors are revealing their subjective bias even in supposedly giving objective facts. As I said, this is on a comparative basis, so when the dollar is said to fall, or oil, or other metals, they "fell", but when gold falls, it is "crashing", "plunging", "undergoing a brutal decline", or "gold falls of a cliff". It is as though the authors are attempting to make the readers feel that there is something extremely negative about a small gold decline, whereas--at least in this corpus of texts--they do not use the same metaphors for other asset classes. Another one that I've focused on is GOLD INVESTMENT IS GAMBLING (it's the convention to put the Conceptual Metaphors in capitals). So authors say things like, "gold bugs are scrambling to reverse their bets," or "speculators are placing bets on lower gold prices", which makes gold investors appear like idiots who are only gamblers, and not using their intelligence to invest in gold. Again, these types of metaphors are not present to any significant degree in relation to other asset classes, so the bias is demonstrated from the comparative nature of the study. And of course, calling someone a "gold bug" is evaluative to a significant degree. Business discourse in general uses a lot of animal metaphors, such as bulls and bears, to represent different market actions, but it appears that gold investors are considered such a fringe that it necessitated naming them their own animal species in metaphorical terms in business discourse.

                Anyway, I wasn't able to use the search function. Could someone post the link to the webpage where that quote is located? I would really appreciate it. I will let you know more about my dissertation once I make more progress on it. There are certainly pedagogical implications. Even native speakers tend to be unaware of the types of values--and what are termed latent ideologically-loaded metaphors--that are contained in the business texts they get their news from.
                the link to the post is above...

                http://www.itulip.com/forums/showthr...558#post239558

                tis in part ii behind the paywall. if you have a quote from there you were a subscriber, non?

                the entire ej post there is...

                --

                Thank you for the kind words.

                For those who didn't see my comments on the other thread I said:

                I've discovered at the various meetings I've had with Fed economists and others who attend meetings there that there is no faster way to clear the table after dessert than to bring up the topic of gold.

                They really, really, really do not like to talk about gold.

                But over the years some have learned that I'm not a journalist but an analyst; I'm not going to quote them on my web site to create controversy and traffic for me and headaches for them. That's not our business model. So one or two have opened up a bit.

                One official gave me his personal and unofficial thoughts on what might happen in the highly, no extremely, no next to impossible event that the USD is officially associated with gold in some fashion some day off in the nearly infinite future. With all of those qualifications preceding his comment, he went on to give his opinion. It was an enlightening conversation and a window into a thought process.

                It was not what I expected. Hint: No high taxation as I have been discussing here since 2001. The expectation is that a high gold tax rate will criminalize gold and create a black market, the opposite of what they want. They want an optimal tax rate on gold that generates the highest tax receipts for the IRS but without creating a black market. He pointed me to this paper. In fact there is concern, he said, that the existing classification of gold as a collectible may cause the tax rate to be too high if the gold price keeps rising; as the gold price rises, so does the incentive for gold holders and dealers to conspire to evade taxes.


                The academic paper uses forumulas and several thousand words to explain the obvious: A rational tax authority seeks to tax at the maximum level that does not create a black market in the item taxed, because once a black market is created it tends to take on a life of its own, will consume major resources to erradicate, and calls the entire tax regime into question.

                That said, the gold market is small, gold is anathema to the central banking community that in any case works primarily in the interests of the finance industry and gold isn't ever going to make investment bankers any money so I doubt we'll see the kind of bubble-friendly capital gains tax policy during the gold price run-up that we got under Clinton to goose the tech bubble to its Q1 2000 crescendo to push the budget into surplus with windfall capital gains tax receipts. Not unless there were 1000s of gold miners that Wall Street could bank.

                A high gold price is a major embarrassment to central bankers. When I got in the gold price was still giving central bankers an A for the fine job they did running a 30-year credit bubble and making everyone rich. At $1750 the gold market is giving central bankers a C. At $2500 they will be giving the central banks a D and at $5000 plus an F, at which point a clear Plan B will already be underway and visible to the connected and/or astute.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Question about the origin of a specific E.J. quote

                  by the way metal, good to see you around still. You have been quiet.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Question about the origin of a specific E.J. quote

                    Originally posted by charliebrown View Post
                    by the way metal, good to see you around still. You have been quiet.
                    thx, chuck. ej advised us to kick back & enjoy the show.. been doin' that...



                    i stop in occasionally to see if i oughta sit up & pucker up again ala mar 2000 & dec 2007 when ej's radar saw the last ones a'coming.

                    ps... not like mega... pining for the next crisis.
                    Last edited by metalman; 07-03-14, 11:04 AM.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Question about the origin of a specific E.J. quote

                      Originally posted by metalman View Post
                      thx, chuck. ej advised us to kick back & enjoy the show.. been doin' that......
                      i stop in occasionally to see if i oughta sit up & pucker up again ala mar 2000 & dec 2007 when ej's radar saw the last ones a'coming.

                      +1

                      atta boy!
                      altho eye have noted that you also seem to pop in whenever the metal markets start to get... uhhh... interesting?

                      but better be paying attention to this radar the next couple, as they saying Arthur is gonna rain on the parades - altho it looks like just a typical boomer'cast for up north, eh MM?

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Question about the origin of a specific E.J. quote

                        Originally posted by shiny! View Post
                        HOW did you do that??? I've tried many times to use the search tool here and find it next to useless.
                        trick with the itulip advanced seach thing is to throw total sentences at it... not keywords ala google. Uroshnor had that... made it easy. if you look based on 3 - 5 words from memory... fuggedaboudit.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Question about the origin of a specific E.J. quote

                          Originally posted by metalman View Post
                          trick with the itulip advanced seach thing is to throw total sentences at it... not keywords ala google. Uroshnor had that... made it easy. if you look based on 3 - 5 words from memory... fuggedaboudit.
                          That's cool. Didn't know Search could take full sentences. Thanks bunches!

                          Sometimes Search leads to a lonnnnnng page that contains the result but it's hard to find. When that happens I do "Ctrl" + "f" to find it. In the little "Find" box I'll enter a word from my query in order to highlight it. In this case I entered the word "astute" and it took me right to the quote.

                          Be kinder than necessary because everyone you meet is fighting some kind of battle.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: Question about the origin of a specific E.J. quote

                            Originally posted by metalman View Post
                            trick with the itulip advanced seach thing is to throw total sentences at it... not keywords ala google. Uroshnor had that... made it easy. if you look based on 3 - 5 words from memory... fuggedaboudit.
                            My Age of 'Tulip Heroes has dimmed, just a bit . . . .

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: Question about the origin of a specific E.J. quote

                              Originally posted by don View Post
                              My Age of 'Tulip Heroes has dimmed, just a bit . . . .
                              yowch! mr don! mercy!

                              ok, ok. i take it back.

                              tried a keyword search vs the whole sentence advanced search...

                              Search Types: Posts

                              Keywords:
                              high gold price embarrassment central bankers

                              User Name: EJ

                              1st item returned is correct.

                              Search:
                              Search took 0.08 seconds.


                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X